Product Comparison

An independent research company was recently commissioned by a major petrochemicals company to find the best solution for managing inspection work.

They selected Credo as the best solution. Credo was then implemented across their entire European refining operation - a total of 7 large refineries. This work was completed within 12 months.

The table below highlights the key differences between Credo and another widely-used system:

 

Piping and Equipment Management

Credo
Competitor

Piping and Equipment Management

Unlimited Equipment Types

Flexible Equipment hierarchy

User-defined Equipment Templates

Automatic Inheritance of technical and process data from parent equipment to child components or test points

Dynamic grouping of equipment

Windows Explorer-style interface

Equipment Archive Feature

Export equipment data to MS Excel

Copy and Paste technical data

Create user-defined pick lists of common codes or values

Spell checker


Customization Features

Credo
Competitor

User-defined language files to support national language or corporate terminology

Spanish only

Value based color formatting

Create custom data entry templates for technical data and inspection reports

Create custom Views of data

 

Anomaly Management / Repair Tracking

Credo
Competitor
Search and filter

Create reports

Track Anomalies

 

Corrosion Management

Credo
Competitor

Minimum Wall Thickness Calculator (T-min)

Self documenting T-min calculator

Manual data entry of thickness readings

Spreadsheet-style data entry window

Automatic color coding of readings based on Alarm status

Automatic calculation of Alarm Thresholds

Manual setting of Alarm Thresholds

Material Code Table

Piping Schedule Table

Active / Inactive reading flag

Requires manufacturers communications software

Graphical Trend Analysis

Stores up to three possible retiral dates, corrosion rates and correlation per TML

Limited to one

Fixed format reports

Graphical profile of thickness on a range of test points

Copy TML’s

Unlimited number of TML’s per location

 

Data Loggers

Credo
Competitor

Import thickness readings

Import A-Scans

Import B-Scans

Import comments

Automatically create Anomaly or Defect records

Build and store library of Work-packs

Optionally export last available reading to datalogger

Import and Export with MS Excel

Import and Export with delimited text file

Supports Panametrics 26 DL Plus

Supports Panametrics 36 DL Plus

Supports Panametrics EPOCH III

Supports Panametrics EPOCH IV

Supports KrautKramer DMS2

Support StressTel T-Scope III

 

Interface with SAP and MAXIMO

Credo
Competitor

Synchronises SAP Equipment Details

Raise notifications in SAP

Synchronises MAXIMO Equipment Details

Raise notifications in MAXIMO

 

Risk Based Inspection (RBI)

Credo
Competitor

In-house developed and maintained (not supplied by a third party company)

User Programmable (the user can develop their own logic)

API 580 Level 1 Compliant

API 580 Level 2 Compliant

API 581 Level 1 Compliant

API 581 Level 2 Compliant

API 581 Level 3 Compliant

Configurable

Self documenting (Export to PDF)

 

Corrosion Models

Credo
Competitor

Stress Corrosion Cracking

H2S

Corrosion Under Insulation

 

Document Management

Credo
Competitor

Support most files types

Integrated file viewer

Launches AutoCAD application

Supports AutoCAD viewing

Dynamic update of AutoCAD drawings

Link external files to Inspection records

Link external files to Equipment records


Enterprise-Wide Document Management

Credo
Competitor

Oracle-based with check-in, checkout and revision control

 

Not available

Web-enabled (Intranet) software

Credo
Competitor

Supports Internet Explorer 4 and greater

Not available

Workflow

Read and write

Multi-level security

 

Inspection Management

Credo
Competitor

Unlimited inspection types

User defined Inspection Templates

Inspection scheduling

Schedule Inspections for Multiple Equipment Items simultaneously

Supports Custom Inspection Types

Spreadsheet style listing of Inspections

Planning Matrix style listing of Inspections

Standard filters – All Overdue, Planned by date range etc.


Reporting

Credo
Competitor

MS Word export

MS Excel export

Color reports

Custom Report Designer

Intelligent Reports – show only relevant data

Automatic embedding of digital photographs in custom reports

 

Application Security

Credo
Competitor

Assign users to membership of Groups which share similar permissions

Field Level security associated with User Groups

Manage multiple sites in a single Oracle database instance

Operating system authentication. User account linked to Windows Logon account

Enforce user data entry method, e.g. typing / select from lookup table


 





 
   
   

 

 

 

 
   

© Credosoft Limited 2008